• Careers FAQs Client login
Two and a Half Centuries of (Real) Interest RatesTwo and a Half Centuries of (Real) Interest RatesTwo and a Half Centuries of (Real) Interest RatesTwo and a Half Centuries of (Real) Interest Rates
  • Home
  • Services
    • Foreign Currency Risk Management
    • Interest Rate Risk Management
    • Fund Finance Services
    • Investment Products
  • Industries
  • Our Technology
  • About
    • Who we are
    • Culture
    • Careers
  • Our Team
  • News & Insights
CONTACT US
✕
            No results See all results
            Fed Tapering: Uncertainty and Unforeseen Consequences
            24 August 2021
            Stagflation – Nitroglycerin for the FX Market?
            7 September 2021
            31 August 2021
            Categories
            • Insights
            Tags
            INSIGHTS • 31 August 2021

            Two and a Half Centuries of (Real) Interest Rates

            author-Kambiz-Kazemi

            Kambiz Kazemi, Chief Investment Officer


            As market participants put Jackson Hole behind them and celebrate Chair Powell’s conciliatory speech, by driving of equity markets to new all-time highs, the key question is whether the observed inflation is transitory as viewed by Chair Powell. We are at a crucial decision point, with two paths ahead: A) continued accommodative policy in the face of rising inflation which, if proves not to be transitory, may lead to untamed inflation, and B) reducing accommodative policy which encompasses the risk of torpedoing the economic recovery.

            In low interest rate regimes, such as what we witness today, higher inflation can mean negative real interest rates (RR). With 10-year US Treasuries presently at 1.30% and 10-year inflation expectations of 2.4%, the owner of a 10-year bond would expect their investment to “erode” (in terms of purchasing power) by 1.1% per year.

            Negative RR have a wide range of consequences, among others: as bonds become less attractive, savers are de-incentivized and the search for returns will direct inflows into riskier assets of all types, lifting their prices, some would argue, way past their fair valuation. Other consequences might not be known yet.

            Chart 1: US 10-year Real Rates 1998-2021: Recently 2011-12 saw a period of negative real rates

            Two and a half image 1

            Source: Bloomberg

            When facing unusual circumstances, it is worthwhile looking at the past for lessons and pointers. Here, we take a closer look at US inflation and interest rates since 1786, shortly after independence, using the impressive historical data gathered Paul Schmelzing from the Bank of England. [1]

            Chart 2: Two and a half centuries of US real rates (1786 – 2021)

            two and a half image 2

            Source: See footnote (1) and Bloomberg

            No doubt, the world has massively changed in the last two and a half centuries: the gold standard is way behind us, and modern central banking is still rather emergent (the Fed was only founded in 1913). Nonetheless, it is worth looking back, as human behavior and the fundamentals of debt retain important similarities through the times.

            Periods of negative real rates are far from uncommon, but usually have not lasted long

            US real rates have been in negative territory nearly a fifth of time since 1786. However, most of these episodes lasted no longer than two years, except for the period around WWII (1941-1947). Interestingly, this period is the only other time when the Fed had a long-term rate management policy, as the US Government was issuing debt to finance the war effort.

            Table 1: Periods of Negative US Real Rates (RR) – Since 1786

            two and a half image 3

            Source: See footnote (1) and Bloomberg

            Periods of negative real rates were mostly driven by increases in inflation from the supply-side

            This observation is particularly salient and policy makers would be well advised to investigate it. In particular, RR went negative during the American Civil War and both World Wars, driven by higher inflation – due to scarcity of supply given the war effort - as nominal rates remained relatively unchanged.

            More recently, the 1970s drop in RR was also driven by strong inflation given the rise of energy prices due to OPEC action.

            It is quite interesting to note that today’s higher inflation is also driven, similar to these war related episodes - albeit a pandemic is not a war - by the disruption of supply chains and production, transportation challenges, and higher commodity prices.

            The end game?

            A negative RR environment is not a healthy setting for capital markets or the economy at large; the value of money erodes and drives economic agents to decisions that either increase risk and leverage in the system or affect societies negatively via increases in income inequality and poverty.

            Historically, these episodes have ended either because the drivers of inflation “faded” naturally (wars ended, supply shocks dissipated) or because central banks drastically changed their policy approach, for example, the post WWII agreement between the Fed & Treasury, or the legendary rate hikes under Paul Volker.

            Fed Chair Powell is clearly in the “inflation will fade” camp. However, in our view, the Fed’s unprecedented accommodative policy also plays a key role in where we are today. The answer might not lie in one (inflation is transitory) or the other (tapering) but a bit of both. By this we mean that part of the inflation might in fact be transitory and fade, but some inflation of it is likely structural and will stay. For instance, due to widespread adopting of ESG efforts and the effects of climate change on agriculture, among others. So, the most optimal path would be a calibrated adjustment to monetary policy to address the non-transitory part of inflation. If the Fed fails to take this more nuanced approach the consequences can be dire for risk assets and the economy at large.

            [1] Eight centuries of global real interest rates, R-G, and the ‘suprasecular’ decline, 1311–2018, Working Pape, January 2020

            Be the first to know

            Subscribe to our newsletter to receive exclusive Validus Insights and industry updates.

              Share

              Related posts

              2 June 2023

              Reviving Concerns: Central Banks and Inflation Regain the Spotlight


              Read more
              31 May 2023

              The market meets (the Fed’s) expectations


              Read more
              24 May 2023

              Will the labour market be the answer to the MPC’s prayers?


              Read more
              Validus-white-logo
              Services

              Foreign Currency Risk Management

              Interest Rate Risk Management

              Fund Financy Advisory

              Investment Products

              Industries

              Private Capital

              Pensions Funds

              Corporates

              Our Technology

              RiskView

              TradeView

              PortfolioView

              London

              19 Wells Street
              London W1T 3PQ
              T. +44 (0) 203 923 8575

              Eton, UK

              119-120 High Street
              Eton, SL4 6AN
              T. +44 (0) 175 338 6548

              Toronto, Canada

              10 King Street East, Suite 800
              Toronto, Ontario M5C 1C3
              T. +(1) 416 646 0590

              New York, United States

              222 Broadway, 19th Floor
              New York, NY 10038
              T. + 1 929-219-3793

              T&Cs | Privacy Policy | Regulatory

              Copyright 2022. All rights reserved. Validus Risk Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (firm reference 555972), is licensed by the CFTC and is a member of the NFA (ID 0504990). Validus Risk Management Limited is incorporated in England and Wales (registration number 07140753), with its registered office at 119-120 High Street, Eton, Windsor, Berkshire, SL4 6AN, United Kingdom.

              CONTACT US
                        No results See all results