• Careers FAQs Client login
What next for Central Banks?What next for Central Banks?What next for Central Banks?What next for Central Banks?
  • Home
  • Services
    • Foreign Currency Risk Management
    • Interest Rate Risk Management
    • Fund Finance Services
    • Investment Products
  • Industries
  • Our Technology
  • About
    • Who we are
    • Culture
    • Careers
  • Our Team
  • News & Insights
CONTACT US
✕
            No results See all results
            Adopting the Higher for Longer
            1 March 2023
            Contagion and Containment – SVB23
            13 March 2023
            7 March 2023
            Categories
            • Insights
            Tags
            RISK INSIGHT • 7 MARCH 2023

            What next for Central Banks?

            author-Marc-Cogliatti

            Marc Cogliatti, Head of Capital Markets EMEA


            Three weeks ago, I highlighted that central banks across the globe may be forced to keep rates higher for longer given the secondary risks to inflation arising from higher wages and embedded inflation expectations. At the time, I was thinking about what this might mean for growth. However, as these risks become more pronounced, an arguably more important factor to consider is what will happen if central banks choose to become more tolerant towards higher prices. Rather than keeping rates higher for longer, or even tightening policy further to bring inflation down to the 2% target rate most central banks have adopted in recent years, what would happen if they decided to accept higher inflation and shift their target rate to 3-4% instead?

            Addressing the issue in the FT, former Bank of England Chief Economist, Andy Haldane, called for central banks to adopt a more flexible approach. Higher prices, he explained, are a result of dislocations in global supply chains, buffeted by geopolitical crosswinds. The end of the golden age of globalisation, and the fact that it will take a long time for supply chains to be repaired, mean that the traditional approach to dealing with inflation will not have the desired effect this time around.

            In his opinion, sticking with rigid inflation targets will either result in them being continuously missed (assuming the central banks do not tighten enough) or it will unnecessarily damage any green shoots of growth (if they continue to raise rates). Instead, he proposes a more flexible approach involving either transparently lengthening the horizon upon which inflation will be expected to return to target or, more radically, temporarily suspending the target all together and pledging to reinstate it at the earliest possible future date.

            Chart 1: Core inflation across the US (blue), Europe (purple), and the UK (orange) has shown little sign of abating in recent months.

            Picture1 70323

            Source: Bloomberg

            While this sounds like a relatively sensible approach, it raises two issues. First and foremost, if the markets sense that central banks are losing control, this will likely lead to a sharp rise in volatility, particularly in the rates and FX markets. Although the cause was different, the market reaction to the fiscal policies of former UK Prime Minister Liz Truss’ government is a good example of what can happen in a stressed market environment. In terms of direct impact, the cost of borrowing rose sharply for anyone with debt while the volatility resulted in a loss of confidence across the investor spectrum. Secondly, if central banks give the impression that they will tolerate inflation, even if it is just in the short term, higher prices will prevail – triggered by supply and demand-side factors alike. This would make it even more difficult to bring inflation back under control further down the line.

            Chart 2: The cost of borrowing for 10y shot up dramatically in the UK last September as the Liz Truss budget rocked market confidence.

            Picture2 70323

            Source: Bloomberg

            From a markets perspective, while central banks will keep short-term rates low, the longer end of the curve will rise sharply as markets price in an increased risk premium and higher rates further out. Volatility in FX markets is also likely to rise sharply, particularly if different central banks adopt different policies. For example, if the Bank of England temporarily suspends its inflation target while the European Central Bank elects to stand firm, the pound will almost certainly come under heavy pressure against the euro. If all the major central banks adopt a similar approach, it might lessen the extreme directional bias, but increased volatility will likely prevail nonetheless.

            Ultimately, it feels like there is no easy way out. While looser monetary policy may ease some of the pain in the very short-term, the longer-term consequences are potentially even more troublesome and damaging than the situation we currently find ourselves in.

            Be the first to know

            Subscribe to our newsletter to receive exclusive Validus Insights and industry updates.

              Share

              Related posts

              2 October 2023

              Central Bank Meetings and Stubborn Curve Inversion


              Read more
              27 September 2023

              Is the Market Finally Seeing the Hawks Circling Overhead?


              Read more
              20 September 2023

              Growth or Inflation – The Central Banks’ Dilemma


              Read more
              Validus-white-logo
              Services

              Foreign Currency Risk Management

              Interest Rate Risk Management

              Fund Financy Advisory

              Investment Products

              Industries

              Private Capital

              Pensions Funds

              Corporates

              Our Technology

              RiskView

              TradeView

              PortfolioView

              London

              24 Torrington Place, 3rd Floor
              London WC1E 7HJ
              T. +44 (0) 203 923 8575

              Eton, UK

              119-120 High Street
              Eton, SL4 6AN
              T. +44 (0) 175 338 6548

              Toronto, Canada

              10 King Street East, Suite 800
              Toronto, Ontario M5C 1C3
              T. +(1) 416 646 0590

              New York, United States

              222 Broadway, 19th Floor
              New York, NY 10038
              T. + 1 929-219-3793

              T&Cs | Privacy Policy | Regulatory

              Copyright 2022. All rights reserved. Validus Risk Management Limited is authorised and regulated by the Financial Conduct Authority (firm reference 555972), is licensed by the CFTC and is a member of the NFA (ID 0504990). Validus Risk Management Limited is incorporated in England and Wales (registration number 07140753), with its registered office at 119-120 High Street, Eton, Windsor, Berkshire, SL4 6AN, United Kingdom.

              CONTACT US
                        No results See all results